Will Arab-Baiting Get Dems Re-elected?


“We now smell the scent of victory.” That was how Charles Schumer, the demagogic Senator from New York responded to the announcement that Dubai Ports World, the international shipping company that had bought the British firm P&O and thereby acquired the management contracts on six U.S. ports, would divest P&O’s U.S. holdings (which make up only ten percent of its operations) in order to complete the deal. But the “case” against Dubai Ports World acquiring those management contracts amounted to nothing more than the fact that it was owned by an Arab country. Schumer and his ilk, however, saw in this an opportunity to make the xenophobic fear-mongering of the Bush administration work to his own party’s advantage, essentially by outdoing the Republicans on “protecting” America from a phantom menace. Dubai, they said, was a country “implicated” in 9/11 — two of the hijackers had been born in the UAE, and they had funneled money through the place. The fact that liberals who get all gooey about George Clooney’s expose of McCarthyism in “Goodnight and Good Luck” can segue so smoothly into exactly the same tactics of innuendo and guilt-by-the-most-distant-of-associations is, frankly, astonishing, and deeply worrying. Dubai was no more implicated in 9/11 than was Germany, where one of the cells planning the operation was based. And because shoe bomber Richard Reid and the London subway bombers were born in Britain, do we consider Britain “implicated” in Qaeda terrorism, too?

Moreover, this was simply a matter of ownership, i.e. the movement of capital. The personnel who would operate the port are the same International Union of Longshoremen members as have been there since Marlon Brando could’a been a contender. Security arrangements at U.S. ports are in the hands of the U.S. government regardless of who owns them — and frankly, that’s where the debate should have been focused. Instead, the Democrats relied on pressing the buttons on the worst instincts cultivated in the U.S. electorate by the Bush administration since 9/11. The politics of fear, so eloquently denounced at the last Democratic onvention by Jimmy Carter, appear to have become a mainstay for the likes of Schumer and Hillary Clinton.

Throughout this sordid affair, nobody has offered any coherent case why the Dubai Ports World management of U.S. ports would constitute a security risk. Only vague innuendo about Arabs and 9/11. The fact that Dubai has been a loyal ally against Al Qaeda and that its shipping company has an impeccable security record — so much so that the head of Israel’s main shipping company testified that his company was proud to be associated with DPW and wrote to Clinton urging her to drop her opposition to the deal.

A few facts were never going to spoil a good argument here. Plainly, the purpose was political — it was a vehicle for the Democrats to press the Administration on its own strong suit (I have no hesitation here in saying that Bush was absolutely right about this issue), stoke up a wave of hysteria that forces the Republicans in Congress to back away from the White House, hoping that it would generate the momentum they so badly lack, largely because the likes of Hillary and Kerry won’t take a coherent, let alone principled stand on issues like Iraq. Schumer scents victory, does he? One wonders what that choice of words reveals: Could it be a latterday equivalent of the “Southern Strategy” adopted by the Republicans from the Nixon years onward — of appealing to the racism of the Democrats traditional base among white voters in the South? If the Democrats only response to their inability to convince voters is to adopt the GOP’s politics of fear, they don’t deserve to win anything.

This entry was posted in Situation Report. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Will Arab-Baiting Get Dems Re-elected?

  1. Once again, Tony hits it on the nail!

    Speaking of excluding not only Dubai but also Germany and the UK, I suggest Americans should be banned from running American ports. Hey, America didn’t just harbor the 9/11 terrorists: it taught them how to fly airplanes! Not even Dubai did that.

    The Dems have everything brought to them on a silver platter: NSA wiretapping, illegal detentions, runaway deficits, high gas prices, Katrina, scandals galore, the Iraq quagmire…
    But no, who needs such tasty dishes when you can play the racism card!
    I have a new name for Democrats: “Republicans who happen to lose elections.”

  2. Pat S. says:

    I’m glad you nailed this one. I’ve found the whole deal rather ironic, in that this is a case of an Arab company playing the capitalist field, just as America would ideally have them do, yet the company was xenophobed out of play, as you described.

    Let’s hope the same folks don’t go after the horse-racing industry next. Those Saudi princes own some great thoroughbreds.

  3. Tony says:

    Yeah, and a lot of oil, too!

  4. ibs says:

    Outstanding post… thank you for writing such wonderful and insightful pieces.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *