As Egypt Goes…

You may have noticed that I don’t update this site much any more — that’s because I’m doing most of my writing on these matters on TIME.com and at the National, and doing my blogging on Facebook and Twitter (follow: @TonyKaron ) I’m not going to update this often, so follow me on those platforms. But for the record, a few of my recent Egypt pieces:

What the US Loses if Mubarak Goes

The revolt that appears to have fatally undermined President Hosni Mubarak’s prospects for remaining in power is a domestic affair — Egyptians have taken to the streets to demand change because of economic despair and political tyranny, not the regime’s close relationship with Israel and the U.S. But having tolerated and abetted Mubarak’s repressive rule for three decades precisely because of his utility to U.S. strategy on issues ranging from Israel to Iran, Washington could be deprived of a key Arab ally with his fall from power.

…the Egyptian rebellion may stand as the ultimate negation of the Bush Administration’s “moderates vs. radicals” approach to the region: Mubarak’s ouster might be a loss for the moderate camp, but it won’t necessarily translate into a gain for the radicals. Instead, it marks a new assertiveness by an Arab public looking to take charge of its own affairs, rather than have them determined by international power struggles. Even that, however, suggests turbulent times ahead for American Middle East policies that have little support on Egypt’s streets.

Egyptians No Longer Tolerate a Dictatorship Backed by the US Because of Israel and Iran

On Saturday, CNN’s Wolf Blitzer asked a guest on his show how al Qa’eda fitted into events in Egypt. The question itself was reminiscent of Larry King a few years back asking Tibet’s spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, to explain yoga….

Fear of Islamists Paralyzes Washington (Time to get over it!)

…Democracy movements are attractive to Washington when they target a regime such as Iran’s, but in allied autocracies, they’re a problem. There’s no way for Egypt to be democratic and exclude the Islamists from political participation. The same is true for most other parts of the Arab world — a lesson the U.S. ought to have learned in Iraq, where Islamists have dominated all the democratically elected governments that followed Saddam Hussein’s ouster. But when the Islamists of Hamas won the last Palestinian elections in 2006, held under pressure from Washington, the Bush Administration literally did a 180-degree turn on the question of Palestinian democracy…

Explaining why the U.S. continues to support Mubarak, the State Department’s Crowley on Thursday told al-Jazeera that “Egypt is an anchor of stability in the Middle East … It’s made its own peace with Israel and is pursuing normal relations with Israel. We think that’s important; we think that’s a model that the region should adopt.”

The problem for Washington is that Arab electorates are unlikely to agree. The democratically elected Iraqi government, for example, despite its dependence on U.S. support, has stated its refusal to normalize relations with Israel. A democratic Egypt, whether led by the Muslim Brotherhood or any other opposition party, is unlikely to go to war with Israel given the vast imbalance in military capability, but they’re even less likely to accept normal ties given the present condition of the Palestinians. And the most secular liberal activists in Egypt reject with contempt the argument that regional stability can come at the expense of their right to choose their government.

Egypt: Obama Caught in a Bind

The Administration is caught in a bind, but it’s more strategic than just moral: Supporting tyrants loathed by their own people but willing to do Washington’s bidding in international matters is a decades-old U.S. tradition in the Middle East, as well as in Asia, Africa and Latin America. The problem with Mubarak is not simply that his methods are at odds with professed U.S. values; it’s that his brittle autocracy appears to have entered a period of terminal decline, with the U.S. potentially on the wrong side of history.

And for old time’s sake, a piece wrote in 2003 on Egypt and Bush’s ‘democracy agenda’

…Democracy in the Middle East and nearby Muslim lands would almost certainly restrain cooperation with the U.S. war on terror. Just look at what happened in Turkey on the eve of the Iraq war: Washington had simply assumed that Ankara would jump into line once the U.S. was on the march to war — after all, the country had been effectively ruled since World War II by generals closely aligned with Washington. But Turkey is far more democratic today, and when it was left up to the elected parliament to choose, the U.S. request to invade Iraq from Turkish territory was declined. And it’s a safe bet that if Jordan and Saudi Arabia had put the matter of their own cooperation with the Iraq invasion to a freely elected legislature, the response would have been the same as Turkey’s….

…The biggest test of the seriousness of President Bush’s commitment to promote democracy will come in Egypt, which is due to hold parliamentary elections in 2005. Egypt is especially vulnerable to U.S. pressure as the recipient of around $2 billion annually in U.S. aid, as its reward for making peace with Israel in 1979. “The great and proud nation of Egypt has shown the way toward peace in the Middle East, and now should show the way toward democracy in the Middle East,” Bush intoned. But if Egypt were a democracy, it’s far from certain that it would still a peace treaty with Israel.

Egypt is a good illustration of President Bush’s point that the absence of channels for democratic political participation in Arab states has helped foster terrorism, which has eventually been exported. Osama Bin Laden may be Saudi, but most of the top-tier al-Qaeda leadership at the time of 9/11 were veterans of Egyptian Islamic Jihad, a militant offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood that turned to terrorism in response to the Sadat regime’s peace treaty with Israel, and found hundreds of willing recruits in Egypt’s middle class and in its officer corps. The Brotherhood, of course, is a far more moderate Islamist entity than Jihad, originating in early 20th agitation against British colonial rule. It enjoys a strong, some say dominant, presence among Cairo’s professional classes, and has eschewed violence. Although its activities are formally banned and it is precluded from contesting parliamentary elections, Egypt analysts suggest it may nonetheless be the dominant opposition force in Egyptian society. The impact of the U.S. invasion of Iraq on Egyptian public opinion has also seen a growing alignment in the views of the Brotherhood and more traditionally liberal democratic opposition groups, around the questions of democracy and sovereignty. Today, the overarching criticism of the Mubarak regime is that it is more responsive to Washington than to its own citizenry, and the internal demand for democratic reform is linked with opposition to, rather than support for U.S. policies….

This entry was posted in Situation Report. Bookmark the permalink.

89 Responses to As Egypt Goes…

  1. Loved my last trip to egypt! Hope all that people get some peace.

  2. bookjersey says:

    “Do I think I had a down year? It’s upfor debateHere are some of their responses:”Well, you know, the league is so hard on players these daysRivers Mario Manningham Jersey was dominating, completing 17 of 23 passes for 270 yards tolead the Chargers to scores on six of theirfirst seven possessions” The Bengals offered a buy-one, get-one-free promotion to season-ticket holders in the hopes of filling the stadium for the season finale The Cowboys scored on four of five first-half possessions to build a 28-0 lead, and the Bucs were limited to one first down Tim Hightower Jersey and 55 yards total offense until late in the third quarter “Coach [Lovie] Smith is a good motivator,” Tillman said When you stop learning, what’sthe point of living? I’m always learning from Ed Reed Jersey Coach, whether it bedecision-making, blocking, running a hitch routeRayo Vallecano is also a club that had been in talks with Adu about signing him last summer before Arian Foster Jersey Adu settled on a return to MLS

  3. The 4 Gambling was a traditional past time back in England in the 1800′s and brought over to the U Call your mom – you know she’s dying to hear from you! Never waste your time while doing cardio Lunar regolith transforms into translucent forms through a process called agglutination when the regolith is subjected to high heat

  4. A man named Bill France saw the potential in turning this racing event into a big, major American sportWarner did pass The more you think ahead about it, the better it’s going to turn out

  5. Dear Tony Karon,

    I expect your comments are moderated and this will reach you and not the whole world.

    I have a question from an Iranian News Agency, nasimonline.ir – which disseminates its news in Persian and Arabic – To Iran and Arab countries:

    The Iranian Supreme (spiritual) Leader gave a speech on Friday in Tehran:

    http://english.khamenei.ir//index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1581

    What effect do you think this will have on global events?

    Requesting a two paragraph answer

    Will send you a link where you are response is published

    I am sure you are very busy – but please, requesting a few minutes of your time for this.

    Hopefully yours

    Morris

  6. It’s terrible what happened to that people after the match. Hope they find some peace.

    Best wishes for them.

  7. How much one can benefit and how often treatment is required depends on many factors including age and acuteness or age of condition They needed something more they can rely on, something

  8. Interesting perspective tony.

  9. This is a heck of a post.

  10. Brake collins says:

    Thanks Tony, This is the nice politic critcism

  11. Susanna juan says:

    Nice post for you Tony, But you didn’t update so long?

  12. Mike Thompson says:

    Hi tony do you remember me? Mike thompson.

  13. i agree How much one can benefit and how often treatment is required depends on many factors including age and acuteness or age of condition They needed something more they can rely on, something

  14. WOw It’s terrible what happened to that people after the match. Hope they find some peace.

    Best wishes for all

  15. WOw It’s terrible what happened to that people after the match. Hope they find some peace.

  16. Talk about, Joe, Joe played the game in my opinion, OK. Jaguars defense rarely left to chance Joe came very comfortable with the ball. Joe and Big characteristics similar to the ball a long time, must be extrinsic to take over the ball after ran out of neutral. Like a long pass out to take over the case is seen in prison, less ready to hand, fear of the INT.

  17. arma says:

    blok se mi bayithanks

  18. my_bilet says:

    kop byslead thks

  19. Francis says:

    This is the nice politic critcism

  20. Your feedback is very interesting

  21. Francis says:

    Hope all that people get some peace

  22. Angi says:

    WOw It’s terrible what happened to that people after the match. Hope they find some peace.

  23. Angi says:

    It’s terrible what happened to that people after the match. Hope they find some peace.

    Best wishes for them.

  24. Lenmath says:

    Nice post for you Tony,

  25. joseph says:

    Meticulously branded as “Livable Luxury”.

    Sobha Concordia gated community is a mix of 230, 3BHK and 4BHK Apartments with a perfect blend of style and elegance. Located near HAL Airport on Old Airport Road, it enjoys close proximity from Marathahalli Junction.

  26. Abe Bird says:

    You are rolling you private scope on history by all the wonderful values of Bolshevik propaganda. First of all, most of the world’s Jews support Israel and Zionism, if only for the fact that more than half of them already live in Israel. Most European Jews loyal to their heritage because the lefty disease of extreme liberal leftism had not stuck to them. Even most American Jews support Israel; how many leftist of Jewish descents live in America? As a simple fact a leftist of Jewish descent is not really a Jew, but a leftist. Leftist socialist values trying to deny the existence of the Jewish people and its state and deny the Jewish faith. According to this method a leftist priest will try to deny with the help of Jesus the wisdom of Christian who would like to be a human being without being a Christian; or a leftist doctor will try using a few phrases of Stalin’s “wisdom” to avoid from his patient to recover. It’s obviously known that Marxist ideology rejects nationality and for that it can’t be applied to argue against Zionist – Jewish national hood. You can’t use linguistic laws to solve Mathematical problems. You can’t solve the Jewish problem with your communists’ rules and propaganda. Equally, leftist Jews lying to themselves when they dismiss the Jewish nation and the right of the Jews to their own national state judging by their communist ideology that denies nationalism of any sort, and at the same time to be the greatest supporters of Palestinian Islamic nationalism!!!!!!
    It’s a Great World Jewish leftist stupidity!!!!

  27. jennifer says:

    wow, its the extreme political, just look at the way this goes,..

    http://www.builderslaunch.com/

  28. jessy says:

    Hope this will resolve very soon,..

    http://youtu.be/u0yzIk86Nqc

  29. VGTV:Se intervju med Demidov etter kampen her! Vi forstår at staten trenger tid på å fatte sin avgjørelse, og vi er selvsagt villig til å forlenge vårt tilbud i tid, sier Olav Fjell. I vår globaliserte økonomi bygges store formuer i raskt tempo. Det kan være ting som “hvor er mamma når hun sover”? Begreper skal gruppere likeartede fenomener og markere et skille i forhold til fenomener med andre egenskaper. Spillernes talsmann, keeper Håkon O

  30. Its offices are afterward apt the proposed site.000 jobs the port supports, spending maximum of the marathon nestled inside the top 10,Nike Zoom KD 6,” he said. Houston GM Rick Smith was capable to garner one of the better two-way firm ends among the draft. was expected apt residence its muddled quarterback situation early amid this design yet days one plus two came within went for the Texans scored with amount picks amongst the third circular winning their last four games by double digits. whic

  31. Anonymous says:

    En el plano personal su mejor clasificación en el Tour de Francia fue la decimocuarta plaza en 2005, edición en la que se adjudicó una etapa en Saint Lary Soiulan. El juegoEl juego que ha tenido toda esta acogida es protagonizado por un niño de 12 años llamado Finn, quien anda siempre con Jake, que no es una mascota cualquiera, sino un que goza de mágicos poderes. Barrientos informó de 6 casos de delitos electoralesEl mayor general Wilmer Barrientos inform&#243

  32. frivers says:

    Siempre y en todo momento es bueno buscar gente que
    tenga exactamente los mismos intereses que uno.
    Es por ello que llegué a tu lugar y me parece que tus artículos son excelentes.
    No deseo sonar halagador mas la verdad creo que tienes potencial al escribir.

    Me gustaría que tuvieras luego la oportunidad de repasar ciertos artículos que he escrito por mi cuenta.
    La verdad es que no se si son tan buenos como los tuyos pero intento hacer
    algo al respecto. Que bien es encontrarte en la red y espero
    que sigas escribiendo que por aquí ya cuentas con un fan.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>