Israel in Deadly Denial

Guest Column: Uri Avnery As dozens of Palestinian civilians are killed in Israel’s fierce retaliation for the latest round of rocket fire, the veteran Israeli peace campaigner Uri Avnery discusses the inevitable — it may take the death of hundreds or even thousands more Palestinians, and scores more Israelis, but in the end, Israel will talk to Hamas.

The Bush-Olmert policy, since Hamas won the Palestinian legislative elections two years ago, has been a catastrophic failure. Attempts to cajole the Palestinians through collective punishment (economic and military) into overthrowing Hamas have, if anything, strengthened its hand — and the collaboration of the Fatah leadership with many of these efforts has simply accelerated the political eclipse of the preferred Palestinian interlocutors of the U.S. and Israel.

Clearly, it is the duty of the international community through the UN to protect civilians in conflict situations, and that requires restraining Israel’s attacks on Gaza, and brokering a ceasefire with representative leaders of the Gaza Palestinians to prevent further rocket attacks on Israeli population centers. That means tearing up the absurd Bush Administration policy that has been in effect for two years ago, when we warned on this site that it was time for the U.S. to get real on Hamas.

Only a negotiated cease-fire between Israel and Hamas can bring the carnage in Gaza to an end, and the current violence is not a coherent policy, simply an appeasing of the worst instincts of a mob baying for vengeance. Israel’s deputy defense minister Matan Vilnai last week threatened to unleash a “shoah” (the Hebrew word used to refer to the Holocaust) in Gaza in response to Palestinian rocket fire. (When Mahmoud Ahmedinajad says things a lot less explicit that are deemed to threaten Israel’s elimination, he arouses the ire of the international community and is scolded by the U.N. Secretary General; somehow Vilnai’s threat has passed largely without comment.)

Vilnai’s statement, although he scrambled to explain that he used the word simply to connote its literal meaning, “disaster,” seems to answer the question posed last year by former Knesset Speaker Avram Burg, about the increasingly virulent strain of racism that has emerged in mainstream Israeli political discourse. “I hear voices coming out of Sderot …. We will destroy and kill and expel. And there is a transferist discourse in the government …. We have crossed so many red lines in the past few years. And then you ask yourself what the next red lines that we cross will be.”

In the midst of the fury, Uri Avnery’s view is a welcome dose of calm rationality.

Good Morning, Hamas

By Uri Avnery

We Israelis live in a world of ghosts and monsters. We do not conduct a war against living persons and real organizations, but against devils and demons which are out to destroy us. It is a war between the Sons of Light and the Sons of Darkness, between absolute good and absolute evil. That’s how it looks to us, and that’s how it looks to the other side, too.

Let’s try to bring this war down from virtual spheres to the solid ground of reality. There can be no reasonable policy, nor even rational discussion, if we do not escape from the realm of horrors and nightmares.

After the Hamas victory in the Palestinian elections, Gush Shalom said that we must speak with them. Here are some of the questions that were showered on me from all sides:

- Do you like Hamas?

Not at all. I have very strong secular convictions. I oppose any ideology that mixes politics with religion – whether Jewish, Muslim or Christian, in Israel, the Arab world or America.

That does not prevent me from speaking with Hamas people, as I have spoken with other people with whom I don’t agree. It has not prevented me from being a guest at their homes, to exchange views with them and to try to understand them. Some of them I liked, some I did not.

- It is said that Hamas was created by Israel. Is that true?

Israel did not “create” Hamas, but it certainly helped it along in its initial stages.

During the first 20 years of the occupation, the Israeli leadership saw the PLO as its chief enemy. That’s why it favored Palestinian organizations that, it was thought, could undermine the PLO. One example of this was Ariel Sharon’s ludicrous attempt to set up Arab “village leagues” that would act as agents of the occupation.

The Israeli intelligence community, which in the last 60 years has failed almost every time in forecasting events in the Arab world, also failed this time. They believed that the emergence of an Islamic organization would weaken the secular PLO. While the military administration of the occupied territories was throwing into prison any Palestinian who engaged in political activity – even for peace – it did not touch the religious activists. The mosque was the only place where Palestinians could get together and plan political action.

This policy was, of course, based on a complete misunderstanding of Islam and Palestinian reality.

Hamas was officially founded immediately after the outbreak of the first intifada at the end of 1987. The Israeli Security Service (known as Shabak or Shin Bet) handled it with kid gloves. Only a year later did it arrest the founder, Sheik Ahmad Yassin.

It is ironic that the Israeli leadership is now supporting the PLO in the hope of undermining Hamas. There is no better evidence for the stupidity of our “experts” as far as Arab matters are concerned, stemming from both arrogance and contempt. Hamas is far more dangerous to Israel than the PLO ever was.

- Did the Hamas election victory show that Islam was on the rise among the Palestinian people?
Not necessarily. The Palestinian people did not become more religious overnight.

True, there is a slow process of Islamization throughout the region, from Turkey to Yemen and from Morocco to Iraq. It is the reaction of the young Arab generation to the failure of secular nationalism to solve their national and social problems. But this did not cause the earthquake in Palestinian society.

- If so, why did Hamas win?

There were several reasons. The main one was the growing conviction of the Palestinians that they would never get anything from the Israelis by non-violent means. After the murder of Yassir Arafat, many Palestinians believed that if they elected Mahmoud Abbas as the new president, he would get from Israel and the US the things they would not give Arafat. They found out that the opposite was happening: No real negotiations, while the settlements were getting larger every day.

They told themselves: if peaceful means don’t work, there is no alternative to violent means. And if there be war, there are no braver warriors than Hamas.

Also: the corruption in the higher Fatah echelons had reached such dimensions, that the majority of Palestinians were disgusted. As long as Arafat was alive, the corruption was somehow tolerated, because everybody knew that Arafat himself was honest, and his towering importance for the national struggle overrode the shortcomings of his administration. After Arafat, tolerating the corruption became impossible. Hamas, on the other hand, was considered clean, and its leaders incorrupt. The social and educational Hamas institutions, mainly financed by Saudi Arabia, were widely respected.

The splits within Fatah also helped the Hamas candidates.

Hamas, of course, had not taken part in previous elections, but it was generally assumed – even by Hamas people themselves – that they represented only about 15-25 percent of the electorate.

- Can one reasonably expect the Palestinians to overthrow Hamas themselves?

As long as the occupation goes on, there is no chance of that. An Israeli general said this week that if the Israeli army stopped operating in the West Bank, Hamas would replace Abbas there too.

The administration of Mahmoud Abbas stands on feet of clay – American and Israeli feet. If the Palestinians finally lose what confidence they still have in Abbas, his power would crumble.

- But how can one reach a settlement with an organization that declares that it will never recognize Israel and whose charter calls for the destruction of the Jewish state?

All this matter of “recognition” is nonsense, a pretext for avoiding a dialogue. We do not need “recognition” from anybody. When the United States started a dialogue with Vietnam, it did not demand to be recognized as an Anglo-Saxon, Christian and capitalist state.

If A signs an agreement with B, it means that A recognizes B. All the rest is hogwash.

And in the same matter: The fuss over the Hamas charter is reminiscent of the ruckus about the PLO charter, in its time. That was a quite unimportant document, which was used by our representatives for years as an excuse to refuse to talk with the PLO. Heaven and earth were moved to compel the PLO to annul it. Who remembers that today? The acts of today and tomorrow are important, the papers of yesterday are not.

- What should we speak with Hamas about?

First of all, about a cease-fire. When a wound is bleeding, the blood loss must be stemmed before the wound itself can be treated.

Hamas has many times proposed a cease-fire, Tahidiyeh (“Quiet”) in Arabic. This would mean a stop to all hostilities: Qassams and Grad rockets and mortar shells from Hamas and the other organizations, “targeted liquidations”, military incursions and starvation from Israel.

The negotiations should be conducted by the Egyptians, particularly since they would have to open the border between the Gaza Strip and Sinai. Gaza must get back its freedom of communication with the world by land, sea and air,

If Hamas demands the extension of the cease-fire to the West Bank, too, this should also be discussed. That would necessitate a Hamas-Fatah-Israel trialogue.

- Won’t Hamas exploit the cease-fire to arm itself?

Certainly. And so will Israel. Perhaps we shall succeed, at long last, in finding a defense against short-range rockets.

- If the cease-fire holds, what will be the next step?

An armistice, or Hudnah in Arabic.

Hamas would have a problem in signing a formal agreement with Israel, because Palestine is a Waqf – a religious endowment. (That arose, at the time, for political reasons. When Caliph Omar conquered Palestine, he was afraid that his generals would divide the country among themselves, as they had already done in Syria. So he declared it to be the property of Allah. This resembles the attitude of our own religious people, who maintain that it is a sin to give away any part of the country, because God has expressly promised it to us.)

Hudnah is an alternative to peace. It is a concept deeply embedded in the Islamic tradition. The prophet Muhammad himself agreed a Hudnah with the rulers of Mecca, with whom he was at war after his flight from Mecca to Medina. (By the way, before the Hudnah expired, the inhabitants of Mecca adopted Islam and the prophet entered the town peacefully.) Since it has a religious sanction, its violation by Muslim believers is impossible.

A Hudnah can last for dozens of years and be extended without limit. A long Hudnah is in practice peace, if the relations between the two parties create a reality of peace.

- So a formal peace is impossible?

There is a solution for this, too. Hamas has declared in the past that it does not object to Abbas conducting peace negotiations, on condition that the agreement reached is put to a plebiscite. If the Palestinian people confirm it, Hamas declared that it will accept the people’s decision.

- Why would Hamas accept it?

Like every Palestinian political force, Hamas aspires to power in the Palestinian state that will be set up along the 1967 borders. For that it needs to enjoy the confidence of the majority. There is no doubt whatsoever that the vast majority of the Palestinian people want a state of their own and peace. Hamas knows this well. It will do nothing that would push the majority of the people away.

- And what is the place of Abbas in all this?

He should be pressured to come to an agreement with Hamas, along the lines of the earlier agreement concluded in Mecca. We believe that Israel has a clear interest in negotiating with a Palestinian government that includes the two big movements, so that the agreement reached would be accepted by almost all sections of the Palestinian people.

- Is time working for us?

For many years, Gush Shalom was telling the Israeli public: let’s make peace with the secular leadership of Yasser Arafat, because otherwise the national conflict will turn into a religious conflict. Unfortunately, this prophecy, too, has come true.

Those who did not want the PLO, got Hamas. If we don’t come to terms with Hamas, we shall be faced with more extreme Islamic organizations, like the Taliban in Afghanistan.

This entry was posted in Situation Report. Bookmark the permalink.

81 Responses to Israel in Deadly Denial

  1. hi!,I like your writing so a lot! proportion we keep up a correspondence
    more about your article on AOL? I need a specialist on this space
    to solve my problem. Maybe that is you! Having a look ahead to look you.

  2. My brother recommended I may like this blog. He was entirely right.

    This put up actually made my day. You cann’t consider just how so much time I had spent for this information! Thank you!

  3. What’s up, the whole thing is going nicely here and ofcourse every
    one is sharing facts, that’s truly fine, keep up writing.

  4. What’s up mates, its enormous piece of writing on the topic of
    cultureand fully defined, keep it up all the time.

  5. Star says:

    Hi there, its fastidious post about media print, we all be awasre of media
    is a wonderful sourtce of facts.

  6. Most present how driver’s fail to observe the fundamental rule of stopping behind the cease line at alerts.

  7. Excellent web site you have here.. It’s hard to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays.
    I really appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

  8. Hello, every time i used to check weblog posts
    here in the early hours in the morning, since i love to learn more and more.

  9. It works on many things including lightening your entire face and body, lightening dark circles under your eyes,
    lightening and evening out any dark marks, scars, shaving razor
    bump scars, blemishes or hyper pigmentation on your skin. These drugs also may help prevent the painful aftereffects of shingles
    known as postherpetic neuralgia. Tight clothing usually causes friction, which consequently leads to the appearance of dark armpits.

  10. Now back to fruit, although good for you it’s probably not
    a wise idea to be eating unlimited portions of fruit per day as this will lead to excess fructose consumption and some of the
    deleterious health effects. She has instantaneously regained
    hope when none was available. According to the CDC and the National
    Center for Health Statistics, “Heart disease is the leading cause of death for women in the United States.

  11. Mable says:

    Thanks for a marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed reading it, you will be a
    great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and may come back down the road.
    I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great job, have a
    nice morning!

  12. Cheryle says:

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on situation report.

  13. If you see that problems are beginning to develop with your child due to their involvement with video games, it is best that you
    give them a time out. Now you can enjoy your games, kill enemies, save princesses and win races.
    The clerk should know enough to give you options suited for you.

  14. Valuable info. Fortunate me I discovered your website accidentally, and I am
    stunned why this twist of fate didn’t came about in advance!
    I bookmarked it.

  15. Noe says:

    IGF-1 Extreme Matrix Deer Spray is really a highly pure
    liquid deer velvet extract. 2004 & Barling.

    Also visit my weblog; deer antler spray reviews amazon;

  16. Blaine says:

    I would not trade my life for something. It has not occurred over night either.

  17. Pour ceux qui ne sont pas familiers avec la smoke électronique, cela fonctionne presque de la même manière qu’un vaporisateur lightweight, utilisable pour vaporiser différentes sortes d’herbes ou de résines (dabs).

  18. Richelle says:

    Many incompatibilities could have occurred through the upgrade.
    Windows-7 and Windows Vista tend to be less incompatible and also
    the upgrade procedure is likely to be accomplished more easily.
    Windows-8 OS is effective at working in capsules,
    which are becoming an increasing number of common today.

  19. Gilberto says:

    El fin último de la rehabilitación cognitiva es progresar la calidad de vida del paciente su habilidad para marchar tanto en el hogar como en su comunidad.

  20. It’s wonderful that you are getting ideas from this article as well as from our argument made

  21. youtube says:

    By keeping the advice you have just read in mind, you can start using online videos for reaching your desired audience online easily.

    ‘Vine Videos’, which is a mobile app owned by
    Twitter, uses mini-videos that are no longer than 6 seconds as a
    marketing tool. Online marketing will be at its best and firms will make all possible efforts to improvise
    their online marketing skills getting more visible using the
    various social platforms and creating user engaging content.

  22. Thank you, I’ve recently been looking for info about this subject for
    a long time and yours is the best I have came upon so far.
    But, what concerning the bottom line? Are you sure
    concerning the source?

  23. What’s up to all, it’s truly a nice for me to pay a quick visit this site, it contains important

  24. WOW just what I was searching for. Came here by searching for quizzes

  25. Pretty! This was an extremely wonderful article.
    Thank you for supplying this information.

  26. Isabelle says:

    It’s aan remarkable piece of writing foor all the internet viewers; they will get advantage from it I am sure.

  27. Forr tips, advice and help on the best Internet Marketing Video strategies, go to his website:
    Acct now and discover how average people are achieving
    extraordinary results business productivity online standard.
    If you are new to Internet Marketing you may not be awsre of the fact that thhe search engines can provide
    you with the best possible traffikc around. So
    iif this is the kind of opportunity you want to follow
    right instantly after reading this article, it
    will be the beginning of a task that will surely change your whole life.

  28. Hi there everyone, it’s my first pay a quick visit at this web site, and post is genuinely fruitful designed for me, keep up posting these types of articles.

  29. Thanks , I’ve recently been looking for information approximately this subject for a while and
    yours is the greatest I’ve came upon so far. However, what in regards to the conclusion?
    Are you sure about the supply?

  30. Automotive Applications. Positive DC Voltage.

  31. ??????????? says:

    I am actually happy to glance at this web site posts which Israel in Deadly Denial | Rootless Cosmopolitan – By Tony Karon contains lots of helpful facts, thanks for providing these kinds of information.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>